Home Free Library Store
Free Catalog



Save with a Two Year Membership

To post in the forums see the Forum Guidelines.
Join or Renew Today.
New Benefits for all VU Members
Forum Guidelines and FAQ
Main Index Search Posts
Who's Online Log In



Home: Inactive Forums: Underwater Video:
Underwater Housing For A Swim Coach

 

 


ybdogsct
New User

Jul 14, 2004, 10:02 PM

Post #1 of 6 (3388 views)
Shortcut
Underwater Housing For A Swim Coach Can't Post

Hello,
I'm new to the forum and have searched online, but couldn't find the answers to my questions.

I am a swimming coach for a team based in Phoenix, Arizona USA. I want to use my Samsung SC-D27 Mini-DV digital camcorder to film my swimmers above and below the water. My plan is to swim beside them while taping their stroke technique from under the water. This will allow my swimmers to identify and correct flaws in their own technique.

I own a Samsung SC-D27 Mini-DV camcorder with dimensions 2.30 inches (width) x 3.54 inches (height) x 6.14 inches (depth). The camera weighs 1.10 pounds. Is there an affordable underwater housing suitable for my purposes? Here are the candidates thus far:

Ewa-Marine (http://www.ewa-marine.com/english/index.htm) N/A
I've read criticisms about Ewa-Marine housings being nothing more than "expensive plastic bags." However, they do seem to offer housings that are universal and inexpensive. Besides, I don't imagine submerging more than 5 feet below the surface for my purposes. Unfortunately, I've already contacted them and they told me they had no housing that would fit my particular camcorder model.

AquaCam (http://www.aquatix.com/aquacam.htm) $459
This looks like a decent solution. My Samsung camcorder does not have a LANC jack, so I would have to settle for manual controls. However, it would be nice to see what I'm shooting to make sure my swimmers are in frame. I don't see how it's possible with this design. I've also read posts warning others about the build quality of this housing.

Epic Cam (http://www.epiccam.com/store/agora.cgi) $269
They have a housing that fits my camcorder. It is the Epic Sport. It has pause/record control to save on battery and tape. But I can't figure out how I will be able to tell if my swimmers are in frame. They seem like a solid company however, and I've read about a few satisfied customers.

ScubaCam (http://scubacam.web1000.com/home.html) $249
This also looks like a decent solution. There is a color LCD monitor to allow you to see what the camera is shooting. But, it's not availabe yet, it's "coming soon." But I have not heard about this company on any forum I've surfed.

Atmo-Seal (http://www.atmoseal-eng.com/aquavaul.htm) $419
This is slightly more expensive. There is an optional LCD monitor available for $239. It also has start/pause control, which will help save battery and tape. Again, I have not heard about this company on any forum I've surfed.

Does anybody have any suggestions? Does anybody have any experience with the companies and housings above (particular the last 2)?

Thanks,
John


(This post was edited by ybdogsct on Jul 14, 2004, 10:11 PM)


sjspeck
Novice


Jul 19, 2004, 10:04 PM

Post #2 of 6 (3320 views)
Shortcut
Re: [ybdogsct] Underwater Housing For A Swim Coach [In reply to] Can't Post

John,

You certainly seem to have covered the market in looking for an affordable housing. The only one on my under $500 list you didn't have was this one: http://hometown.aol.com/deeeph2o/index.html. I have no experience with them good or bad.

One thing to consider is your plan of swimming along and filming. Video camera housings are hard to move in the water as they're kind of bulky and not particularly hydrodynamic since most are designed for gradual filming movements while diving so it does take some effort to move them along quickly. You might want to consider trying one before you buy to be sure that you can swim along while filming. Another thing you'll have to consider is that you'll have to add about 4/5 lbs. in some sort of weight system for the housing you get, either external - usually mounted on the bottom, or internally if there's room. This is so the housing is neutrally buoyant so you're not fighting to keep it down. My Sony camcorder in a Quest Polyurethane housing takes about 4-5 lbs. of weight to make it neutrally buoyant in a freshwater swimming pool.

I'd go for the smallest, simplest housing you can get your camera into, sacrificing some of the control functionality as it will add drag since the more complex the controls, the bigger the housing will have to be to accomodate them. Especially since with no LANC control on your Samsung, the controls would have to be mechanical levers. With a clear housing or a view to your remote eye, you can always stop/start the camera by pointing your remote control at it prior to entering/leaving the water and just let the video run while in the water. Most people shooting video use a small remote monitor located at the back of the housing since it's almost impossible to see thru the viewfinder on a camcorder in a housing. I do it, but I also do a lot of filming while following slow moving fish. Or you learn to point and shoot, with a wide angle lens most things are clearly in focus from about 2-40' underwater.

Any of the inexpensive tube-type housings will probably do what you want. I'd favor the Epic, they're used by surfers so they're pretty durable. Most of the tube housings will be too small in diameter to open and use your camera's LCD monitor, so what you'll want to do is get a separate LCD monitor and mount it on the back inside face of your housing and connect it to the video output on your camcorder. There's several options to do this - the one from Atmo-Seal is a Citizen M329 monitor, sometimes you can buy them cheaper on eBay. Also check for housings on eBay, sometimes they're pretty reasonable and all you'd have to do is ensure that your camera would fit. Although you will have to get one with a flat front port as the lens on your Samsung is probably in a different position than Sony's, which is what most housings are designed around. There's also a guy on eBay periodically that sells a simple tube type housing with basic/no controls for under $200. Yellowjacket or something similar...

Another really inexpensive option for viewing what you're filming is to buy a used LCD TV with a Video Input jack, there are about 4-5 of them that are small enough to fit inside a 5-6" dia tube housing and they're a lot cheaper than a standard LCD monitor - used I've seen them for as little as $50, again on eBay. The one thing watch in addition to the height is that some of them are too thick to fit between your camera battery and the back face of the housing. There are several 2.3" TV's made by Radio Shack and Casio that I considered once for a similar project, they would probably have worked as they were less than 1-1/2" thick.

One last option you might want to consider is going with an inexpensive Sony setup. For your purposes, there's a housing made by Sony called a Marine Pak, designed to just protect your camera from the elements, it's not a dive housing, but allows you to film underwater to about 2m deep. They're available on eBay quite often for under $50. Cheap Sony 8MM camcorders that fit them are also available on eBay for under $100 all day long. Although they are very specific as to the camera model(s) that they fit. They have LANC control and are pretty streamlined around the camera body. They might have a tendency to float, but they have a tripod mount so with a little ingenuity, you could mount a dive weight to the bottom. Downside is that I've never seen one with space for an add on monitor, but it would be a cheaper option than buying a housing for your Samsung DV camera, unless you have to use it for some reason. There's a couple on eBay right now, do a search for Underwater Video Housing.

I'm in Phoenix, so contact me if you need any further info, matrix@att.net

regards,

Steve


sjspeck
Novice


Jul 19, 2004, 10:34 PM

Post #3 of 6 (3316 views)
Shortcut
Oops!! [In reply to] Can't Post

The Sony housings named in my previous posting should have been Sports Packs not Marine Packs. The Marine Packs are dive housings. There's two currently on eBay, one's at $17.50 and an older one's at $9.99 currently with 5 days to go in the auction.

Steve


ybdogsct
New User

Jul 25, 2004, 6:57 PM

Post #4 of 6 (3249 views)
Shortcut
Re: [sjspeck] Underwater Housing For A Swim Coach [In reply to] Can't Post

Thanks for the feedback. I'm not sure I can afford a new camcorder right now. I was hoping for something I could use with my current one. The Epic Cam certainly seems promising, but it looks like they use a black plastic rear cover which would prevent me from mounting an LCD monitor. I guess I could simply turn the camcorder's LCD screen to face outward and view from the side. This seems to me to be an awkward solution, however.

Do you know of any places in Phoenix that rent gear for an affordable price?

Thanks,
John


sjspeck
Novice


Aug 3, 2004, 9:56 PM

Post #5 of 6 (3182 views)
Shortcut
Re: [ybdogsct] Underwater Housing For A Swim Coach [In reply to] Can't Post

John,

I took a look at the pictures on the Epic website. It appears to have a black back. Although I think it that might just be a black protective cover for the back plate that they forgot to remove for the picture. Every housing of this type I've ever seen have optically clear front and back covers since most people use their camcorders w/o using their lcd's, in order to see through the viewfinder, the back would have to be clear.

I don't know about the LCD on your camcorder, but Sony's wouldn't be usable installed in the Epic housing, it's only 5.5 inches wide so you can't extend it enough to be viewable from behind. The Sony monitor does work fully turned around and retracted, but as you said it would be really difficult to view from the side.

What you might wind up doing, no matter what housing you get is just setting your camcorders lens to a wide angle position and shooting via the point/shoot method. When I set my camera to it's second from widest position, everything from about 18" to about 30' is in clear focus. You'll probably find that you'll set your camera to a fixed focus anyway and film from that distance, otherwise the autofocus will go crazy trying to focus on the swimmer moving, the wake he's making etc. I have a lot of blurred underwater footage where my camera was autofocusing on entirely something other than I was.

I don't know of anyone in Phoenix that rents housings. Backscatter in L.A. does, but I doubt they'll have a housing specifically for your camcorder. If you just wanted to try it out, they'll rent you a Top Dawg generic housing for $25/day. The controls wouldn't work with your camcorder since it's set up for a Sony with LANC control, but at least you could turn your camera on, seal it in the housing and try it. They allow 2 free days for shipping so it's actually a pretty good way to try it out.

You could call around to the scuba stores in Phoenix and see if they might have something you could rent or even borrow once. A lot of more expensive scuba gear is try before you buy. So you could take advantage of that if you wanted to, although you'd probably have to have a certified diver rent for you. Although I don't really know of anywhere locally that rents housings, the places I'd suggest calling are El-Mar in Mesa or Ocean Planet in Tempe, I think they do some video work themselves.

In my previous post, I wasn't suggesting you get a new camcorder. The Sony SportsPacks sell generally on eBay for under $50 and since they take older cameras, you can pick one up used for less than $100, which would be cheaper than the Epic housing is new. I bought an older Sony TR30 8MM camcorder last year for $40, worked great except I had to buy a battery for it. I've read in eBay listings that the SportPacks are good for something like 7-10' underwater. The only thing to watch out for is the condition of the seals, if they're shot, I doubt you can get replacements from Sony anymore.

I also just saw a housing for a Sharp Viewcam, the kind with the 4" LCD screen on the back, it might be ideal for what you want since it would be easy to view while filming. I don't know what the housing sold for, but the cameras sell for well under $100 on eBay all the time.

e-mail me at steveswork@att.net if you need more info. Or if you wanted to discuss any of this, you can call me at work - (www.matrixgroup.biz) for the number, I don't want to post it here.

Steve


padi_instructor
New User

Aug 27, 2004, 4:49 AM

Post #6 of 6 (3067 views)
Shortcut
Re: [ybdogsct] Underwater Housing For A Swim Coach [In reply to] Can't Post

One more you missed.

http://www.clearcam.co.uk