What the Canon 5DmkIII Means To Me

By: Anthony Burokas

 

It’s finally here- the successor to the full-frame DSLR that sparked the entire Video-DSLR revolution (or upheaval as many called it.) On Friday, March 2nd, Canon announced the 5D MarkIII with several notable improvements. But do these make this camera another game changer, or do they just refine what the 5D is in the market?

The Full Frame 5D is back for more in "Mark III"

Truth be told, that as the vDSLR movement grew and successors to the 5D came out, the competitive advantages of the 5D became less and less. Especially in recent months with the release of Nikon’s D4 and D800 series cameras. But the 5DmkIII brings Canon right back up to the bar in terms of capability. So “Cannonites” need not start to consider trying to jump ship to Nikon.

Several key features for videographers stand out:

  • New sensor with 2-more stops of light gathering. Better for low light work. Better to let you close down a lens to get a deeper depth of field and keep focus easier. Reportedly smoother images.
  • New DIGIC 5+ processor. Reportedly greatly diminishes the problematic moire and aliasing that plagues the 5DmkII.
  • New compression choices. Including “All-I” frame compression where each frame is compressed individually- making for much easier editing because a given frame does not have to first decode the frames around it to be seen.
  • Longer recording time. Now you can record up to 30 minutes (instead of 12 minutes on the mkII) and the camera will automatically break the video into 4 GB chunks on a FAT-32 formatted card, a process called “spanning.”
  • A headphone jack. Now you can monitor the actual audio the camera is recording. Coupled with this…
  • Better audio control while recording. 64 levels- adjustable before and during recording. Together, these two features greatly lessen the need for an external audio recorder for many projects.
  • Better LCD screen. If you want to travel light (without an outboard monitor) the improved screen will help.
  • HDMI out no longer drops resolution to SD when recording.

A headphone jack and better audio controls are notable improvements.

But several caveats still remain:

  • No clean HDMI out. If you don’t use an external recorder, this isn’t an issue.
  • Moire & aliasing. The PR says “significantly reducing” moire and color artifacts. It doesn’t say it has eliminated them.
  • The 60 fps video is only 720p, finally reaching what HD camcorders have been doing for many years. This is still less than the new AVCHD spec of 1080p60.
  • Timecode capability. It’s finally there, but given that so many workarounds already exist, it’s not much needed any more.
  • CMOS “jello” remains. It’s a large sensor with lots of pixels so refreshing it faster is still a very hard thing to do.
  • No “crop” modes like Nikon / Panasonic Lumix. These help with using different lenses and also let one lens act as two or three.
  • It’s $3,500 without glass. So, if you really need that shallow depth of field, it’s a choice, but now you are clearly approaching the same cost of real, large sensor, video cameras. If the cost is the same, choose a video camera to do a video camera’s job.

Some improvements, but not a "game changer" because the game has changed around it.

If you are already heavily set up for 5D video, then swapping out the body and getting the new benefits is a no-brainer. If you are new to vDSLR work, then strongly consider a large-sensor camcorder- purpose built for shooting video, as opposed to a vDSLR.

 

In the business for 20 years? He doesn't look it. Anthony Burokas is a 20+ year broadcast TV video producer currently based in Dallas TX. He has produced an extensive body of event, corporate, special interest, and broadcast TV. His web site is IEBA.com

Keep Reading...

Bioshock Infinite – An Interactive Feature Film

This video game is one that all video producers should see. Bioshock Infinite is a graphic masterpiece.

Read More
Transfer videotapes

David Pogue says Digitize Those Memory-Filled Cassettes

David Pogue produces videos and writes articles about personal tech issues. His work appears in the NY Times, PBS “Nova,” Yahoo Tech, Scientific American and more. His new article “Digitize Those Memory-Filled Cassettes before They Disintegrate subtitled Bite the bullet and have them digitized—I wish I’d done it sooner. appears in the September 1, 2016 […]

Read More

Incredible Movi Stabilizer, Game Changer?

The MōVI M10 is produced by Freefly Systems of Seattle WA. The device is a digital, 3-axis, gyro-stabilized camera gimbal.

Read More
GoPro HERO4 Session Camera

GoPro HERO4 Session Camera Price Cut From $399 to $199

GoPro HERO4 Session Camera Price Cut From $399 to $199 The GoPro HERO4 Session Camera is the smallest, lightest GoPro yet. It features easy one-button control to power up and capture videos or stills with one press. The camera captures 1080p60; 720p100; and 1440p30 video. This camera is waterproof down to 33 feet so it […]

Read More




3 thoughts on “What the Canon 5DmkIII Means To Me

  1. Hal Post author

    This had me very interested till we got to the price – ouch! The question is what camcorders compare at the price point of most video DSLRs?

  2. Anthony Burokas

    It’s an okay price for a high quality hybrid (stills & video) device. But as a professional video camera, it’s still pretty steep as this price includes no lens, no decent microphone, etc.

    At this $3500 price, you can start getting a decent prosumer video camcorder that is properly suited to shooting video, for longer periods of time, with better audio & control, video measurement and assessment, easier direct access to control parameters, and a whole lot more.

    The Canon XF100 is $2995 new.
    The Canon XH-A1s $2649 new
    The JVC HM150U is $2600 new.
    The Panasonic AC130 is $3695 new.
    The large sensor Sony NEX-VG20 is $1600 new.

    There are even “pro” 3D camcorders from Panasonic, Sony, & JVC under $3300.
    All of these have dedicated audio controls and XLR inputs, smooth servo zoom lenses, and enough depth of field that half your shots won’t be out of focus.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Subscribe to Video Entrepreneur, our weekly free email newsletter
Whether you're a veteran of the film and video business
or you're just starting out, you've come to the right place.