OS X Better Than Windows For Video Editing?

This Video May Surprise You

Which is Faster OS X or Windows?

There’s more to the story than simply the speed of the operating system for video editing, rendering and more, but this test did a good job of equalizing the variables to make it a valid test comparing just the operating systems using the same hardware and editing application. Another factor to compare is which system you know the best and especially what system are the freelancers you want to work with using.

Operating system doesn’t necessarily have to be a deal killer as far as who you work with because many of the files created in one system can be easily read and edited in another. This works best if you use the same cross-platform program. If, for instance, you use CS6 (Adobe Cloud) and format a hard drive as eXFat, then both WIN and MAC systems can read it just fine. The drive does, however, have to be formatted by a Windows machine.

There are also drives that are cross platform out of the box such as the Seagate Seven 500GB Hard Drive.

But before choosing an operating system and computer hardware, choose the editing software. Final Cut Pro X, for instance, only runs on Mac. Sony Vegas is only for Windows.

Compare carefully the cost of the system and hardware upgrades. Computers become obsolete, no matter which system you choose. To learn more see the article Choosing An Editing System.




Keep Reading...

Logmar Super 8 Film Camera

First New Super 8 Camera in 30 Years Features Film AND Digital Technology

New Super 8 Film Camera with XLR audio and digital technology. First new Super 8 in 30 years.

Read More
Atomos Ninja 2 Captures Pro Res for Less than $300

Atomos Ninja 2 Captures Pro Res/DNxHR for under $300

Atomos Ninja 2 Captures Pro Res/DNxHR for under $300 First Pro-Res/DNxHR monitor-recorder under $300 The new Ninja 2 from Atomos captures Apple ProRes and AVID DNxHD recording from HDMI cameras for less than $300. The monitor-recorder allows any HD camera to record to a pro format. It avoids the internal MPEG compression. Your output goes […]

Read More
New GoPros And A Drone

2 New GoPros And a Drone

GoPro introduces 2 new GoPros and a Drone. The new Hero 5 Black ($399 )includes a 2-inch touch screen display. The new Hero 5 Session ($299) is intended as an entry level camera. Both cameras have built-in waterproof casings, good for up to 10 meters. Both cameras can shoot 4K video at 30 frames. The […]

Read More
Quicktime For Windows Malacious Threat

QuickTime for Windows Vulnerable to Exploit

Trend Micro, the software security company, warns there are two “critical vulnerabilities” in QuickTime for Windows and advises users to uninstall this program immediately. The Homeland Security Department also posted a warning https://www.us-cert.gov/ncas/alerts/TA16-105A based on Trend Micro’s findings and also recommends that PC users remove QuickTime from their systems. Apple stopped supporting QuickTime for Windows, […]

Read More


One thought on “OS X Better Than Windows For Video Editing?

  1. Cinema Pete

    This kind of question is at the core of misconceptions about Windows vs Mac operating systems or Mac vs Windows, which ever way you want to phrase it. The guy in the video says he doesn’t know where this kind of question originated. Most of these misconceptions, such as the one posed by the video and in particular that Mac computers cannot be infected are rampant among Mac aficionados and is perpetuated on the general public. (I can send anyone that requests it a list of security breaches and alerts regarding Mac operating systems that proves the point that Macs are not invulnerable.) Most of these myths have developed during the early years of Apple computers as a result of them touting that their computers were more “artistically” focused and easier to use. Nonsense. Apple’s marketing was slick and effective in making it appear that Windows was a crude race car only good for one thing, and that Apple computers were more sophisticated and could do “artistic” things that Windows computers could not. To the point of the video and the question it poses, we have to define what is “better” for video editing? In terms of video editing neither a mac or a PC is categorically “better”, unless we’ve defined what better really is. The video ran a few tests and compared a Windows PC to a Mac but didn’t indicate the specifics of the hardware such as processor speed, amount of RAM memory, speed and type of hard drives, etc, for either the Windows PC or the Mac computer. Hardware has an effect on general speed and how quickly a particular video operation is completed. For example, you can equip a Windows computer, with the right motherboard, to support dual XEON Processors, each with 8 to 16 cores for a total of 32 cores. Similarly, you can equip a Mac Pro with Xeon processors. Even running a video test on a Windows machine with a single Xeon 6 core or 8 core process will likely blow away most other Windows machines if and ONLY if the video editing software can take advantage of multiple processors. Similarly, the same machine might perform remarkably poorly because the editing software will only use one or two cores or may only be designed to use a single core. Assuming you’re running an editor program that recognizes multiple processor cores (and graphics card cores) then it becomes a question of what hardware configuration is it being run on and that generally boils down to processor speed, number of cores, and the amount of memory/memory speed in system. Also, doing video transcoding is very processor and memory intensive so if you’re transcoding a single HD video on a machine with dual cores as opposed to a machine with quad cores or more than 4 cores – regardless of whether it is a Windows or Mac – you’ll likely see faster performance on the machine with more cores. But does that translate and mean the operating system, which ever it is, Windows or Mac, on the machine with more cores that completed faster than the machine with less than 4 cores is a better operating system for video editing? Absolutely not. All it means is that the machine that finished faster had faster hardware.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  • Forbes Magazine calls VideoUniversity one of the best business-to-business sites for digital video production.
  • WINNER
    Videography Magazine's
    "Website of the Month" Award
  • WINNER
    PC Magazine Online "Best Desktop Video Site" Award
  • WINNER
    CyberFilm School's "FOUR STAR" Award